Michael Gaydosh, John Herringer and Scott Syracuse all members of the Board of Directors of Calvary Press and Elders of Grace Reformed Baptist Church of Merrick, New York, the corporate owner of Calvary Press were each successively exposed as unfit to remain in each of their respective church positions and subsequently removed from their offices over the few years following Michael Rotolo's departure in July 1998. To this day none are employed in full-time pastoral ministry.
John Herringer and Scott Syracuse were essentially encouraged to resign for what can be charitably summarized as a general lack of confidence in their abilities to rule well.
More grievously, Mike Gaydosh was made to resign his position as Senior Pastor/Elder due to a serious moral failure by which he revealed himself to be biblically and morally unfit for service as a pastor. The sin (despite the report of his repentance under the examination of the church) is of a nature that would prohibit his future resuming of an elder/Pastor office in countless church denominations.
Bearing that in mind, it has come to my attention that he has or is seeking to resume an office of ministry at his local church.
Additional history here http://rotolo-media.blogspot.com/2003/09/corruption-rife-at-calvary-press.html .
